The Mellor Law Firm, APLC

California Real Estate, Construction, Bankruptcy, Foreclosure and Business Litigation Lawyers

    • Facebook
    • LinkedIn
    • RSS
    • Twitter
    • YouTube

Call: (951) 221-4744

  • Our Firm
  • Attorney Profile
  • Practice Areas
    • Real Estate Law
    • Construction Law Attorney
    • Experienced Foreclosure Attorney Serving Riverside Homeowners
    • Business Law
    • Chapter 7 Bankruptcy
    • Chapter 13 Bankruptcy
    • Contract Disputes
    • Insurance
    • Loan Modifications
    • Personal Injury & Wrongful Death
  • Case Handling
  • Clients
  • Blog
  • Contact

Copyright Misuse.

April 28, 2015 by Leave a Comment

CopyrightCostco purchased luxury watches from a company in New York who had purchased them from an overseas company who had purchased them from the manufacturer, and sold the watches in its U.S. Costco stores. Omega, the Swiss manufacturer of the luxury watches, sued Costco for copyright infringement, specifically the importation of copyrighted work without the copyright holder’s permission. The first time around, a federal district court granted summary judgment to Costco based on the first sale doctrine under 17 USC § 109(a), which means that once a copyright owner consents to the sale of particular copies the a work, that same copyright owner cannot later claim infringement for distribution of those copies. After the case proceeded to the Ninth Circuit, which reversed because the watches were first sold overseas, and then to the United States Supreme Court which affirmed the Ninth Circuit’s decision [562 U.S. 40 (2010), the case was remanded to the trial court. On remand, the district court again granted summary judgment to Costco, finding that Omega misused its copyright to expand its limited monopoly impermissibly. The district court also granted Costco its attorney fees. This time, the Ninth Circuit affirmed, stating that Omega “eliminated price competition in the retail market for Omega watches and deprived consumers of the opportunity to purchase discounted gray market Omega watches from Costco.  Omega misused its copyright by engraving the Globe Design on the underside of its watches, and attempting to use copyright law to eliminate intrabrand competition from Costco in the retail watch market.” (Omega S.A. v. Costco Wholesale Corp. (Ninth Cir.; January 20, 2015) 776 F.3d 692.) 

Filed Under: Copyright Law News, Legal News, Ninth Circuit Court of Appeal Law News

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Call Us: 951-222-2100

Consultations available in-office or over
the phone. Speak to one of our leading attorneys in California today.

Recent News

Buying Your First House: Here is What You Need to Know About Mortgages

August 15, 2023 By Mark Mellor

Congratulations! You're ready to take the leap into homeownership, an exciting journey that begins with understanding mortgages. A mortgage is a loan provided by a lender that helps you to buy a house. You repay this loan, with interest, over a specified period. Let's dive … Read More...

Involved in a Construction Accident? Know the Types of Compensation Available

August 8, 2023 By Mark Mellor

Construction sites are bustling with activity, but amidst the organized chaos, accidents can occur, leading to severe consequences for those involved. Construction accidents can result in devastating injuries, significant medical bills, lost wages, and emotional trauma. If you … Read More...

Failure to Disclose: What Are Your Rights If a Home Seller Conceals a Defect?

July 5, 2023 By Mark Mellor

When it comes to buying a home, transparency is crucial. In the real estate world, sellers have a legal duty to provide buyers with written disclosures that outline any known defects or material facts about the property. These disclosures are designed to protect buyers and ensure … Read More...

Follow Mellor Law Firm

    • Facebook
    • LinkedIn
    • RSS
    • Twitter
    • YouTube

Our Areas of Practice

  • Comprehensive Real Estate Legal Services
  • Construction Law Attorney
  • Mechanic’s Lien – Stop Notice
  • Experienced Foreclosure Attorney Serving Riverside Homeowners
  • Business Law
  • Contract Disputes
  • Chapter 7 Bankruptcy
  • Chapter 13 Bankruptcy
  • Insurance
  • Lien Stripping Bankruptcy
  • Loan Modifications
  • Personal Injury & Wrongful Death
  • Property Ownership

Navigate

  • Home
  • Our Firm
  • Mark Mellor
  • Practice Areas
  • Case Handling
  • Clients
  • Resources
  • Contact
  • Blog
  • Privacy Policy

Practice Areas

  • Comprehensive Real Estate Legal Services
  • Construction Law Attorney
  • Mechanic’s Lien – Stop Notice
  • Experienced Foreclosure Attorney Serving Riverside Homeowners
  • Business Law
  • Contract Disputes
  • Chapter 7 Bankruptcy
  • Chapter 13 Bankruptcy
  • Insurance
  • Lien Stripping Bankruptcy
  • Loan Modifications
  • Personal Injury & Wrongful Death
  • Property Ownership

Recent Posts

  • Buying Your First House: Here is What You Need to Know About Mortgages
  • Involved in a Construction Accident? Know the Types of Compensation Available
  • Failure to Disclose: What Are Your Rights If a Home Seller Conceals a Defect?
  • Are Verbal Agreements Legally Binding in the Construction Industry?

Follow Us

    • Facebook
    • LinkedIn
    • RSS
    • Twitter
    • YouTube

Contact our offices

The Mellor Law Firm, APLC
6800 Indiana Avenue, Suite 220
Riverside, CA 92506
Phone: (951) 221-4744
Fax: (951) 222-2122
10.0Mark Albert Mellor

The Mellor Law Firm, APLC © 2023. All Rights Reserved.